Water softener vs water filter: which one do you need?

A water softener takes out hardness, the minerals that leave white scale on fixtures and inside water heaters. A water filter takes out things that affect taste, smell and clarity, such as chlorine taste and sediment, and some homes want both. Friendly Services installs both in Hayward and across the Bay Area; see our water softener and filtration installation page or call (510) 626-9773.

Start here, or go straight to water softener and filtration installation.

What does each one do, and not do?

  • A softener does remove the hardness minerals, calcium and magnesium, that build scale on faucets, shower glass and inside water heaters.
  • A softener does not change chlorine taste or smell, or take out sediment.
  • A filter does take out things that affect taste, smell and clarity, such as chlorine taste and sediment.
  • A filter does not remove hardness, so scale keeps forming.

Signs you want a softener

  • White crust on faucets, shower heads and shower glass that keeps coming back.
  • Spots and film on glassware.
  • Scale inside the water heater, or a tankless unit that needs descaling often. See water heater maintenance.

Signs you want a filter

  • Water that tastes or smells of chlorine: a carbon filter.
  • Grit or cloudiness: a sediment filter, and a check of the old pipe.
  • You want filtered drinking and cooking water at one tap: an under-sink filter or reverse osmosis. See whole-house vs under-sink water filter.

Brown or rusty water usually comes from old galvanized pipe, and neither a filter nor a softener is the fix.

Can you have both?

Yes. They do different jobs, so they work side by side. Both go on the main water line one after the other, in the order the makers call for for the systems you choose. We plan the layout with you before anything is cut in.

What does install look like?

A whole-house filter or a softener is fitted on the main water line where it enters the home, after the shutoff, with a bypass so it can be serviced without turning off the house. A softener also needs a drain line and a power outlet nearby. An under-sink filter goes in the cabinet at the kitchen sink. Most systems go in on one visit, and we tell you the upkeep schedule for your system when it is in.

Softener and filter side by side

Water softenerWater filter
Main jobRemoves hardness (scale)Improves taste, smell and clarity
Chlorine tasteNo changeA carbon filter takes it out
White scaleSlows itNo change
Where it goesMain water lineMain water line or under a sink
NeedsDrain line, power outlet, saltFilter changes on the maker's schedule

Installed prices for common setups are on our water softener and water filtration shop pages.

Who is Friendly Services?

Licensed plumbers with over 20 years in Hayward. CSLB #1156315. Our own work carries a five-year workmanship warranty, and estimates are free. We are based in Hayward and work across the Bay Area, out to Sacramento.

Ready to choose? See water softener and filtration installation.

Friendly Services home · All plumbing services

Service area

We are based in Hayward and serve these East Bay cities. Pick your city for local plumbing information.

Frequently asked questions

Is a water softener the same as a water filter?

No. A softener removes the hardness minerals that leave scale. A filter improves taste, smell and clarity.

Will a water filter stop scale?

No. Scale comes from hardness, which a softener removes.

Will a softener get rid of chlorine taste?

No. A carbon filter deals with chlorine taste and smell.

Can I have a softener and a filter together?

Yes. Many homes have both on the main water line.

What does a softener need to be installed?

A spot on the main water line, a drain line and a power outlet nearby.

Do you give free estimates?

Yes. Call (510) 626-9773.

Call (510) 626-9773

More plumbing answers

Licensed Insured Bonded 5-Year Warranty CSLB #1156315